Choosing Between Car Loans: Dealership vs. Private Loans
When purchasing a new or used car, many potential buyers face the decision of how to finance their purchase. If you're not planning to pay for the car in full upfront, you'll need to consider your loan options.
There are two main types of car loans available— car dealerships and private loans, and each has its own pros and cons.
This Kwiksure guide will explain the features and processes of both types of loans, including important considerations and restrictions, to help prospective car owners make an informed decision about their financial arrangement.
Car Loans via Dealership
Car dealership loans involve obtaining financing through the dealership or an agent. These are secured loans where the vehicle registration document (牌簿) is held as collateral until the loan is fully repaid. During the loan period, the car must be covered by comprehensive car insurance.
There are two types of dealership loans:
Hire Purchase (租購): No down payment is required. This option allows you to drive away with almost no upfront costs but generally comes with higher interest rates.
Leasing (租賃): Requires an initial down payment of roughly 10% of the full price, usually covering the first few months' payments. Leasing typically has lower interest rates compared to hire purchases.
Application Process for Car Dealership Loans
- The dealership or agent handles the application process.
- You'll need to provide proof of income, identity, and address.
- Approval and interest rates are usually communicated within a few working days.
Car Loans via Private Loans
Private loans involve applying directly to banks or financial institutions. This type of loan offers more flexibility in terms of loan amount and interest rates. Private loans generally have lower interest rates compared to dealership loans and do not require the car's registration document as collateral. This means you can sell the car without first settling the loan.
Some banks offer special car loans that cover not only the vehicle price but also insurance, accessories, registration, and license fees, helping reduce overall costs.
Application Process for Private Loans
- Complete the bank's loan application form.
- Submit proof of income, identity, address, and a copy of the vehicle registration document.
- You should receive a response from the bank within five to ten working days.
Comparison of Car Dealership and Private Loans
Dealership Loan (Hire Purchase) |
Dealership Loan (Leasing) |
Private Loan |
|
Repayment Period |
1 to 5 years |
1 to 5 years |
1 to 6 years |
Loan Amount |
Based on the vehicle price |
Based on the vehicle price |
Based on the applicant's income |
Interest Rate |
Depends on vehicle type and condition |
Depends on vehicle type and condition |
Based on credit history |
Collateral |
Vehicle registration document |
Vehicle registration document |
None required |
Insurance |
Comprehensive insurance required |
Comprehensive insurance required |
No specific requirement |
Down Payment |
None required |
Required |
None required |
Advantages |
Convenience of dealer handling; no upfront payment required |
Convenience of dealer handling; lower interest rates compared to hire purchase |
Greater flexibility; buyers can decide which bank to use; generally lower interest rates |
Disadvantages |
Vehicle registration document needed as collateral; must fully repay to re-sell |
Down payment required; registration document needed as collateral |
Requires comparison shopping for the best interest rates; loan amount may not cover full vehicle cost |
Considerations and Restrictions
Credit Card Installments
Some credit card companies offer the option to convert credit limits into installment loans. This might offer lower rates than private loans, but ensure the credit limit is sufficient to cover the vehicle price.
Fees
Banks might charge processing fees or other charges. Always check and understand the terms before committing.
Early Repayment
Most private loans allow early repayment but usually charge a processing fee equal to a certain percentage of the remaining loan balance. Dealership loans might not allow early repayment or may impose higher fees. Remember to check the terms and read the fine print before committing.
Vehicle Age
New vehicles generally face fewer restrictions, but loans for older vehicles (e.g., over 20 years) may not be available through dealerships, leaving private loans as the only option.
Insurance Requirements
Dealership loans require comprehensive insurance for the vehicle. For a loan period of 5 years, the total insurance premiums will at least run into the tens of thousands of Hong Kong dollars. Make sure to factor this into your budget.